Horseshoes might be the most underrated backyard game out there. While cornhole gets all the attention and bocce has its European charm, horseshoes has been a staple of American backyards, parks, and picnics since before any of us were born. There’s a reason an estimated 10 million people play every year.
The appeal is dead simple: throw a heavy piece of metal at a stake in the ground. Get it close and you score. Wrap it around the stake (a “ringer”) and you’re a legend — at least until the next throw. The satisfying clank of steel on steel never gets old.
Horseshoe sets range from cheap plastic toys to professional-grade forged steel used in NHPA-sanctioned tournaments. This guide covers the best options at every level so you can find the right set for how you play.
Quick Horseshoes Primer
If you’ve never played, here’s what you need to know:
The equipment: 4 horseshoes (2 per player/team) and 2 stakes driven into the ground. That’s the entire game.
How to play: Players take turns pitching horseshoes at the opposite stake from about 40 feet away (regulation) or whatever distance feels right for casual play. A ringer (shoe around the stake) scores 3 points. A “leaner” (shoe leaning against the stake) scores 2. Closest shoe to the stake scores 1 point. First to 21 or 40 points wins, depending on what you agree on.
Court setup: Regulation distance is 40 feet between stakes for men, 30 feet for women and juniors. For backyard play, 20 to 30 feet works great. Drive each stake about 12 inches into the ground, angled slightly toward the opposite stake. A patch of sand or loose dirt around each stake makes it easier to drive stakes in and softens the landing area.
What to Look For in a Horseshoe Set
Material determines the experience. Forged steel horseshoes are the gold standard — heavy, balanced, durable, and satisfying to throw. Cast steel is a step down but still plays well for casual games. Rubber and plastic sets are lighter, safer for kids, and work indoors. Each material has its place.
Weight matters for your throwing style. Regulation horseshoes weigh about 2.5 pounds each. Heavier shoes fly straighter and are easier to control for experienced players but can be tiring for beginners, kids, and older players. Lighter rubber or plastic shoes (under 2 pounds) are more forgiving for casual play.
Stakes make or break the setup. Cheap thin stakes bend and wobble. Look for solid steel stakes at least 20 inches long and thick enough to hold up to repeated impacts. Powder-coated or chrome-plated stakes resist rust. Some rubber sets come with rubber mat bases instead of ground stakes — great for hard surfaces and indoor play.
A carrying case is essential. Four steel horseshoes and two stakes add up to 15-20+ pounds. You need a bag or case to keep everything organized and transportable. Sets without cases are a hassle.
Best Horseshoe Sets
1. St. Pierre American Professional Horseshoe Set
Best Overall
St. Pierre is America’s largest horseshoe manufacturer, and this set is their flagship. Four solid American forged steel horseshoes, two solid steel stakes, an official rulebook, and a durable carrying case. Everything you need, nothing you don’t.
The horseshoes are beautifully balanced — heavy enough for consistent throws but not so heavy that casual players struggle. The forging quality is evident the moment you pick one up. These are the kind of horseshoes that make you feel like you’re playing the game the way it was meant to be played.
This set is NHPA-compliant, meaning it meets the specifications for tournament play. Whether you’re setting up a backyard pit or entering a local league, these horseshoes are ready.
Material: Forged steel, powder-coated Weight: ~2.5 lbs per shoe What’s Included: 4 horseshoes (2 colors), 2 steel stakes, rulebook, carrying case Best For: Most players, backyard enthusiasts, anyone who wants a quality set that lasts What to Know: This is the set we recommend for most people. It’s not the cheapest, but the quality justifies the price. These horseshoes will outlast multiple cheaper sets.
2. Franklin Sports Forged Steel Horseshoe Set
Best Value Steel Set
Franklin Sports makes quality outdoor equipment at accessible prices, and their horseshoe set is no exception. Four forged steel horseshoes in grey and black, two chrome-plated solid steel stakes, and a carry bag. It even includes instructions for laying out your court.
The horseshoes are regulation size and weight, with a clean finish that holds up well to repeated play. The chrome plating on the stakes resists rust nicely. For the price, this is a lot of quality — many players find this set comparable to sets costing significantly more.
If you want real steel horseshoes without spending top dollar, Franklin is the way to go.
Material: Forged steel Weight: ~2.5 lbs per shoe What’s Included: 4 horseshoes (2 colors), 2 chrome-plated stakes, carry bag, instructions Best For: Budget-conscious players who still want real steel, first-time buyers What to Know: Great entry point into steel horseshoes. The carry bag is basic but functional. You might upgrade the bag eventually, but the horseshoes themselves are solid.
3. Fun Gripper Rubber Horseshoe Set by Saturnian
Best for Families
The Fun Gripper set by Saturnian is built with safety and portability front and center. Four numbered 100% natural rubber horseshoes (two red, two black) with no sharp edges, two step-in pegs, and a 3-foot carry strap with instructions printed right on the back. It’s designed so anyone — kids, grandparents, total beginners — can pick it up and start playing immediately.
What sets the Fun Gripper apart from other rubber sets is the weight. At 8.5 ounces per shoe, these are noticeably heavier than most rubber horseshoes (which often come in around 6 ounces). That extra heft makes them throw more like real horseshoes — heavy enough for experienced players to land ringers, but still light and safe enough for kids. Reviewers consistently highlight this as the reason they prefer these over cheaper rubber alternatives.
The step-in pegs are a smart design. Just step on them to push them into grass, sand, or dirt — no hammer or mallet needed. The whole set packs up with the carry strap and weighs almost nothing, making it genuinely portable for beach trips, camping, parks, and tailgates.
Material: 100% natural rubber Weight: 8.5 oz per shoe What’s Included: 4 numbered horseshoes (2 red, 2 black), 2 step-in pegs, 3-foot carry strap with instructions Best For: Families with kids, mixed-age groups, travel, beach, parks, indoor play What to Know: Heavier than most rubber sets, which is a good thing — they throw better and are less likely to bounce wildly. The carry strap is simple but effective for transport. Replacement pegs are sold separately on Amazon if you lose one.
4. LesunSport Heavy-Duty Horseshoe Set
Best Budget Steel Set
LesunSport packs a lot of value into an affordable package. Four forged steel horseshoes, two solid steel stakes, and a carrying bag — all at one of the lowest prices you’ll find for a genuine steel set.
The horseshoes are regulation size with a clean finish. They’re slightly rougher in finishing detail than the St. Pierre or Franklin sets, but for backyard play the difference is marginal. The stakes are solid and hold up well in soft ground.
If you want to try horseshoes without committing to a premium set, this is a smart starting point. You’re getting real steel at a budget price.
Material: Forged steel Weight: ~2.5 lbs per shoe What’s Included: 4 horseshoes (2 colors), 2 steel stakes, carrying bag Best For: Budget buyers, first-time players testing the waters What to Know: Finish quality isn’t quite as refined as premium sets, but the weight, balance, and gameplay are good for the price.
5. ISANCHA Rubber Horseshoe Set
Best Portable/Travel Set
The ISANCHA set is designed for playing anywhere — beach, park, campsite, backyard, even indoors. Four rubber horseshoes, two pegs, two rubber mats, and two red plastic dowels, all in a mesh bag for easy carrying.
The rubber construction makes this set lightweight enough to toss in a beach bag or backpack. The mats mean you never need soft ground to play. And the rubber shoes are safe enough for kids to throw without supervision.
This is the set you keep in the car for spontaneous games. Not for serious horseshoe players, but perfect for casual fun anywhere you go.
Material: Rubber Weight: Very light What’s Included: 4 rubber horseshoes (2 colors), 2 pegs, 2 rubber mats, 2 plastic dowels, mesh bag Best For: Travel, beach, camping, spontaneous games What to Know: Similar to the Champion Sports rubber set but often at a lower price point. The mesh bag is handy for sandy/wet environments.
6. YARDCANDY LED Light-Up Horseshoe Set
Best for Night Play
Just like the LED bocce sets we covered in our Best Bocce Ball Sets guide, LED horseshoes turn an evening game into an event. Two weighted blue LED horseshoes, two weighted red LED horseshoes, and two LED stakes — everything glows.
The horseshoes are weighted for a reasonable throwing feel (not as heavy as steel, but heavier than standard rubber). The LED lights are bright and visible from across the court, making night play totally viable. This is the set that comes out at summer evening parties and keeps the game going long after the sun goes down.
Material: Weighted composite with LED Weight: Moderate What’s Included: 4 LED horseshoes (2 blue, 2 red), 2 LED stakes Best For: Night play, parties, camping, anyone who loved the LED bocce idea What to Know: Not regulation weight or material — these are party horseshoes. But they’re a blast after dark and always get a reaction from the group.
You can find the light up horseshoe set at Walmart. For some reason or another it does not seem to be available on Amazon.
Steel vs. Rubber: Which Should You Choose?
| Factor | Steel | Rubber |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | ~2.5 lbs (regulation) | Under 1 lb |
| Feel | Authentic, satisfying | Lightweight, easy |
| Durability | Decades with care | Several seasons |
| Safety | Heavy — adult supervision for kids | Safe for all ages |
| Surface | Soft ground (grass, sand, dirt) | Any surface including indoors |
| Price | $30-$80 | $15-$30 |
| Best For | Serious play, adults, backyard pits | Kids, indoor, travel, hard surfaces |
Our recommendation: If it’s mostly adults playing in a backyard with soft ground, go steel. If kids are involved, you play on hard surfaces, or you want portability, go rubber. Many families own both — steel for the adults and rubber for the kids to play alongside.
Setting Up Your Backyard Horseshoe Pit
You don’t need anything fancy to play horseshoes, but a little setup goes a long way:
Distance: 40 feet between stakes is regulation. For casual play, 20-30 feet is more comfortable and still plenty fun. Adjust based on who’s playing — shorter for kids, longer for experienced players.
Stakes: Drive them about 12-15 inches into the ground, angled slightly toward the opposite stake (about 3 inches of lean). The stake should extend about 12-15 inches above ground.
Pit area: Ideally, dig a shallow box (about 3′ × 6′) around each stake and fill with sand or loose dirt. This gives horseshoes a soft landing, keeps them from bouncing wildly, and protects your lawn. For casual play, just picking a patch of grass works fine.
Orientation: Like cornhole, avoid setting up east-to-west to prevent sun glare. North-south or shaded areas play best.
Horseshoes vs. Other Backyard Games
Already have a cornhole set and a bocce set? Horseshoes adds a different energy to your game rotation. It’s more physical than bocce (you’re throwing 2.5-pound steel), more focused than cornhole (just you and the stake), and has a timeless Americana vibe that nothing else quite matches.
Horseshoes also pairs naturally with the games on our tailgate games list — it’s one of the original pre-game activities and fits perfectly alongside cornhole at any outdoor gathering.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the regulation distance for horseshoes? Regulation distance is 40 feet between stakes for men and 30 feet for women and juniors. For casual backyard play, any distance that feels comfortable works — 20 to 30 feet is popular for recreational games.
How much do horseshoes weigh? Regulation horseshoes weigh no more than 2 pounds 10 ounces (about 2.5 lbs). Recreational steel horseshoes are usually close to this weight. Rubber and plastic horseshoes weigh well under a pound, making them suitable for kids and casual players.
What’s the difference between forged steel and cast steel horseshoes? Forged steel is compressed and hardened under extreme pressure, making it denser, more durable, and less likely to crack or warp. Cast steel is poured into molds and tends to be slightly less durable. Forged steel is the standard for quality horseshoe sets and is used in tournament play.
Can you play horseshoes indoors? Yes, with a rubber or plastic set. Rubber horseshoe sets often include rubber mat bases that sit flat on any surface, eliminating the need for stakes in the ground. They’re light enough that errant throws won’t damage floors or walls. Steel horseshoes should only be used outdoors on soft ground.
How do you score in horseshoes? A ringer (shoe completely around the stake) scores 3 points. A leaner (shoe touching the stake but not around it) scores 2 points in some rule sets, or 1 point in others. The closest shoe to the stake that is within one horseshoe-width scores 1 point. Most casual games play to 21 points; tournament play goes to 40.
Building your backyard game collection? Check out our Best Bocce Ball Sets, Best Tailgate Games, and Best Cornhole Sets for 2025.
This post contains affiliate links. When you purchase through our links, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. For more details, see our Affiliate Disclaimer.